PDA

View Full Version : Guest Editors at DSR? Your thoughts?



Shane R. Monroe
11-13-2006, 11:09 AM
Hey gang ...

Chris and I are talking about creating a 'guest editor' program for DualScreenRadio.com. The games database is growing so fast, we simply aren't able to keep up with it ourselves.

Here is where "guest editors" come into play. We already have a "report inaccuracies" system for the database, but it isn't getting used as much as I'd like. Giving ownership to certain games by the individual would give a little more pride and incentive to keep their entries up to date.

It would work like this. Let's talk about "Bob". Bob is already an avid user of the site to track his own collection, wishlist, watching titles, etc. He has 10-20 games, a couple of imports, and some of the more unusual titles for his kids (like Sprung and Ping Pals). We take a look at Bob's collection - and find that he has a lot of titles not already "owned" by other guest editors and would be a good fit with our needs. Most importantly, Bob has proven himself a valuable, stable member of the DSR society; even tempered, fair, and trustworthy.

We approach Bob and ask him if he'd like to be a guest editor for <insert game(s) here>. We tell him that he will have administrative access to our database for those game entries. This will allow him to control all the information for these games - even upload a new boxshot if a better one comes along. He will be responsible for keeping the entry up to date, as well as handle any error reports that visitors might submit. Since we can't pay anyone, Bob's recognition will be a little ownership placard on the game's DETAIL page stating that he is the information owner of these games.

Bob likes the idea, and picks 5 games from his collection he'd like to maintain. We ask Bob to limit it to 5 for now; once these entries are cleaned up, we can give him more. We add him as the editor for the games he selected and he goes to work, accepting more games if he likes the position or just maintaining the 5 we've assigned him.

I'd like to see guest editors end up "owning" like about 20 games or more over time. This will help us keep the number of guest editors down to a managable amount and clean our database up significantly.

In the beginning, we'd only be taking 1 or 2 trusted members of our community to help us pilot the process, then once we have the code ironed out, we'd bring on more.

What do you guys think about this concept?

miner2049er
11-13-2006, 11:15 AM
If you're as short of time as you say you are, it could really help you out.

It's all about the pride baby, and in that respect it seems like a nice idea.

Chris
11-13-2006, 11:31 AM
hmm, yeah, give it a shot.

Shane R. Monroe
11-13-2006, 11:34 AM
Actually, Chris .. you were one of the first people I was going to approach.

Chris
11-13-2006, 11:42 AM
Oh nice, thanks. I'd be willing to do it. Only thing is, I don't own any imports, my DS games are fairly standard and easy to find games. I'll check in later tonight back at the boards, at the moment I have to get back to work though.

Shane R. Monroe
11-13-2006, 11:59 AM
Rarity isn't really a factor ... and you don't necessarily have to OWN the game physically to own the game in the database (it would be nice though), just means you'd have to do some footwork to find more information.

So many games simply have very little information about mic usage, sendable demos, etc. and if you own and play it, chances are more likely you know about it :)

entexman
11-13-2006, 01:44 PM
Yeah sounds cool to me. I would not mind helping out if later on if you need more help with updating the database.

RetroBob
11-13-2006, 01:46 PM
Haha, wrong forum Shane! Must be the sleepless nights and nappies...

GrilledMonkeyFat
11-13-2006, 02:31 PM
I like how Shane addressed the would-be-editor as "Bob". Reminds me of those male enhancement commercials.

"This...is Bob. Bob is a happy guest editor. But he wasn't always happy. That's when he called about free natural male enhancement from DSR."

Heh, anyways. Yeah, Shane, relocate this to the DSR forum, and delete my stupid ass joke post while you're at it. ;)

Rab Mush
11-13-2006, 03:04 PM
I don't have anything crazy in my collection, but I have noticed some of the titles info on mic usage/touch screen usage inaccurate. I'd like to help :D

BJWanlund
11-13-2006, 03:49 PM
I'll bite. Will be rather interesting to have this in place.

BJ

DaMenace
11-13-2006, 04:52 PM
I'll bite as well! :-D

BorninUSA
11-13-2006, 05:25 PM
I would love to do it for you guys. It would definitly seem like a fun thing some of us.I personally being 13 could do younger games that you guys dont understand (NOT Barbie or Bratz though, or Danny Phantom, im sorry like Womp said cartoons suck in my opinion) But it would be cool:D

alexjlopez
11-13-2006, 05:33 PM
Sounds like a great idea--and I agree, Chris would make a great editor considering the work he's done on the commenting system. :)

sawfish22
11-13-2006, 06:36 PM
Sounds like a solid idea, but you should be focusing on trying to get this "rumored to be 6-Hours Long" show. I can't wait much longer without DSR!

quickstraw
11-14-2006, 07:39 PM
I agree, this sounds like a good idea to me.

Womp
11-14-2006, 08:03 PM
I would love to do it for you guys. It would definitly seem like a fun thing some of us.I personally being 13 could do younger games that you guys dont understand (NOT Barbie or Bratz though, or Danny Phantom, im sorry like Womp said cartoons suck in my opinion) But it would be cool:D

Well, MOST of these newer cartoons IMO suck...Most just seem to insult a kid's intelligence. The writing is horribly lacking. We need some better adventure cartoons that focus on story telling rather than insane MTV wack job humor that seems to be prevalent in today's toons.

Anyway....Back on topic. ;)

Womp
11-14-2006, 08:05 PM
Sounds like a solid idea, but you should be focusing on trying to get this "rumored to be 6-Hours Long" show. I can't wait much longer without DSR!

Don't worry...I think I'm hoarse after today's session and we didn't even finish it yet. :eek:

*"Session"....LOL

CyberFox
11-14-2006, 10:25 PM
Well, MOST of these newer cartoons IMO suck...Most just seem to insult a kid's intelligence. The writing is horribly lacking. We need some better adventure cartoons that focus on story telling rather than insane MTV wack job humor that seems to be prevalent in today's toons.

Anyway....Back on topic. ;)

I agree that shows like Xaolin Showdown and Loonatics Unleashed are polluting our kids' minds

Kids need to see classic (and also) obscure cartoons to grow up with like The Cattanooga Cats, Looney Tunes, Yogi Bear, etc.

Plus, Some cartoons today do not suck like Class of 3000, Foster's Home For Imaginary Friends, Squirrel Boy, Camp Lazlo, Yin Yang Yo! and a few others

Shane R. Monroe
11-15-2006, 05:46 AM
Can I have a game based on Drawn Together plz?

YoshiM
11-15-2006, 05:54 AM
Can I have a game based on Drawn Together plz?

If the Family Guy game was any indication of the quality of an adult cartoon-to-game translation, doing Drawn Together would be a bad idea.

Shane R. Monroe
11-15-2006, 07:12 AM
For those interested in being DSR Associate Editors, please PM me with a list of say, 5 games you'd be interested in taking control of. This way, I get an idea what sort of gaming spread I have to work with.

CyberFox
11-15-2006, 08:17 AM
If the Family Guy game was any indication of the quality of an adult cartoon-to-game translation, doing Drawn Together would be a bad idea.

South Park has 2 video games under it's belt and both of them suck

reefinyateef
12-01-2006, 10:00 AM
Sounds good ... I'm interested.

Shane R. Monroe
12-23-2006, 05:07 PM
Alright, I have a beta of the Editor Console.

I need my Editor volunteers to PM me with let's say 3 games they want to "take care of".

I'd prefer, for this first pilot of the console, that you pick games that are "already out" so we can start purifying the existing data. As we clean them up, we'll add more functionality to the editors and expand their palette of games.

Whoo hoo! Let's rock!